In class, we have been talking about sanctions and the way people are treated when they violate rules, whether they are social norms or even laws. This concept got me thinking what the punishments in the United States are for people caught practicing polygamy. As it turns out this topic, like most regarding polygamy, is quite controversial. I was very surprised by the plethora of articles, blogs, and comments that resulted from my search of "polygamy punishments." This one from usatoday.com, highlights the hypocrisy in the laws that have been passed in the US regarding polygamy.
Apparently, there is no nationwide law (or punishment) for polygamy, but rather it is up to the states to decide what to do with their polygamous residents. I find this to be a poor decision on the part of law makers, simply because by passing the buck of polygamy punishment to the states they are creating disunity in the country. Some states, like Utah, have very lenient rules on polygamy and basically allow the practice as long as it does not cause issues, while other states, like New York, will send polygamous residents to jail for up to ten years. Some states think that polygamy is okay because of its religious connections and simply view it as an "alternative lifestyle" while others could not imagine condoning such a practice.
I feel that this drastic difference in punishment is not fair for citizens who believe in either polygamy or monogamy. Since there is no set government standard for the punishment or tolerance of polygamy, how are the nation's people supposed to know how to react to the topic?
So what do you think? Should the US have a uniform punishment for polygamy? Should it be strict?
No comments:
Post a Comment